‘It’s an extremely sexy story’: how the legendary tale of the ‘rebellious’ Saint Mary of Egypt became a medieval blockbuster

In 11th-century England, a dark-skinned saint with a promiscuous past became a groundbreaking cultural and religious icon. A new study hopes to confirm her place in history.

She was old. She was dark-skinned. As a young woman, she was promiscuous and enjoyed sex. But after rejecting the world and living naked in the desert for 47 years, St Mary of Egypt became a wise and virtuous teacher of Christian scripture—or so 11th-century readers were led to believe.

When the extraordinary legend of St Mary was first translated from Latin into Old English by an unknown author just over a millennium ago, it became the medieval equivalent of a blockbuster novel, copied and translated many times into Old Norse, Welsh, Irish, and eventually Middle English.

Now, Cambridge University is seeking to solve the mystery of how and why the tale of this “rebellious” saint appealed to readers in 11th-Century England, and reassert the rightful place in history of Saint Mary – an elderly Egyptian woman – as a role model for medieval English Christians. 

“There has never been a full in-depth study of why this legend resonated in England,” says Alexandra Zhirnova, a Cambridge scholar who is giving a talk on Saint Mary of Egypt on 22 March as part of the Cambridge Festival – a showcase of the research underway at Cambridge University. “I want to bring this story into the light, because it dispels a lot of the negative stereotypes that we have heard about the Middle Ages, and how medieval Europeans only have negative perceptions of women, particularly women with darker skin. My talk shines a light on how Mary gets adopted as a saint in England during a time when the Church was very concerned with gender norms and how women ought to behave,” Zhirnova tells the BBC.

In this period, adopting a saint was not a formal eclestiastical process. “It just involves people worshipping you as a saint and your legend being known to lots of people,” says Zhirnova. Mary of Egypt, who is said to have lived in 4th-Century Egypt, had already attained the status of a saint across Europe. “But it was only when the story was translated into Old English that it became accessible to ordinary people in England,” says Zhirnova.

Zhirnova will argue in her talk that the legend directly challenges commonly held views of what a holy woman should look like, and that it counteracts the misogynistic teachings of men of the time who emphasised passive obedience to the Church, particularly in the case of women, and strict adherence to rules governing how women should conduct themselves sexually. 

The legend is told from the perspective of an arrogant monk who purports to have met Mary in the desert after she has been living there naked for 40 years.

“She rejects the world to the point that she stops wearing clothes, because she doesn’t need them,” says Zhirnova. She then becomes “like a priest” to the monk, explaining to him what’s wrong with his relationship with God, and quotes to him from scripture, even though she’s never read the Bible. Despite her promiscuity – she had multiple lovers in her youth, it is revealed in the story – the monk looks up to her and realises he hasn’t understood what a true Christian was before. 

“She’s held up as an example of fantastic Christian spirituality,” Zhirnova notes. Yet at the time, most popular female saints were virgins, who became saints after being persecuted for choosing to stay chaste and devote themselves to God.

The existence of Saint Mary – a sexually experienced, naked, elderly Egyptian woman – utterly undermines this stereotype. Yet, Zhirnova says, “the tale suggests this woman, who breaks every single convention that the Church has established for holy women, is a lesson for men on how to be a better Christian.” 

Mary’s debated identity
The Old English translation of the tale states she was “extremely black in her body because of the sun’s heat”.

However, medieval readers did not understand or perceive racial differences in the way we do today. “At that point, they believed that people who have dark skin are dark because they live in places with a lot of sun. So, for example, Ethiopia is a sunny place, therefore people from there have darker skin,” Zhirnova says.

Whether or not Saint Mary is black or just tanned may not have been an issue medieval readers were particularly concerned about. “I truly don’t know to what extent it would have been important to them to make a distinction between being born with dark skin and having it due to being outside a lot, but I think certainly they would have thought of her as culturally different,” Irina Dumitrescu, professor of English Medieval Studies at the University of Bonn, tells the BBC.

It’s an extremely sexy story. There’s a lot of erotic detail in it. It’s a little bit ribald and tantalising – Irina Dumitrescu

In her opinion “what’s important about her dark skin is that it demonstrates that the culture of medieval England is a more cosmopolitan culture that many people tend to assume. They have trade that goes wider than people might think, and they’re interested in learning and stories from North Africa and the Middle East – so their imagination encompasses these areas.”

She adds that lighter skin was idealised in women in medieval England and associated with virginity: “There is often a connection made between brightness of colouring – blonde hair, for example – and purity. So Mary’s darker skin could be associated with a kind of sexuality. That sense of difference is there.”

Why Mary’s story was such a hit

Dumitrescu believes that descriptions of Saint Mary’s “very naughty” youth may account for some of the legend’s popularity among medieval readers. “It’s an extremely sexy story,” she said. “There’s a lot of erotic detail in it. She talks about going on a boat to the Holy Land from Egypt, and how she taught all the people on the boat unspoken lewd acts. It’s a little bit ribald and tantalising.” 

She thinks another reason this remarkable legend became so popular was because “it’s a very human thing to want to know that God also loves imperfect people… The Mary of Egypt tale has a very important lesson that you cannot teach with tales of virgin saints – which is God’s grace. The Church has always needed stories of sinners who can be saved.”

At a time when many of the monastic readers and copyists of the story were living out their whole lives enclosed in an institution, the legend of Saint Mary presented “a very disturbing figure”, according to Dumitrescu, which may be part of her appeal.

Unlike other tales of saints who went off to the desert to devote themselves to God (an ascetic practice known as desert monasticism), Mary of Egypt does not stay in one place. “She is quite unusual, because she’s not even a hermit in a little cave somewhere. She just wanders the desert. She roams freely. She becomes one with nature. She’s naked. She doesn’t seem to be a regular person in any way, even in the way hermits are,” says Dumitrescu. “She’s rogue.”